Investigating an Old Murder Case Built on Circumstantial Evidence, The Medill Justice Project Finds Police Records and Witness Accounts That Don't Add Up

Pittsburgh man serving a life sentence in the wake of a recovered memory from the victim's son, who was 5 at the time of the killing

In an examination of a 1975 murder in a darkened basement, a team of Northwestern University undergraduate students discovered inconsistencies in police and witnesses’ reports, calling into question who saw what and whether the convicted killer pulled the trigger.

The case went unsolved for years. In 1990, the victim’s son approached authorities saying he suddenly recovered a memory of the night of the murder that placed Steven Slutzker, a neighbor, at the scene. A reexamination of the case led to Slutzker’s arrest, conviction and life sentence. Slutzker, 66, has always maintained his innocence.

As part of the investigation, students combed through thousands of records and interviewed witnesses, authorities and others. In an interview for the story, one witness said a police report is “completely wrong.” In another interview, a then-police officer and his wife said the victim’s son was asleep the night of the shooting and could not have seen the assailant.

“What the students uncovered is remarkable, given the age and complexity of the case, and it deserves to be reexamined by authorities because of the significant discrepancies unearthed,” said Northwestern University Prof. Alec Klein, director of The Medill Justice Project, who supervised the students’ work as part of a journalism class he teaches.

The in-depth story published today is the third part in a series titled “Stranger Than Fiction?” and is available at www.medilljusticeproject.org.

In March, MJP published a story exploring the recovered memory in the Slutzker case as well as the broader debate surrounding the issue. Earlier this month, MJP released information about over 100 cases throughout the world involving accusations based on recovered memories in what is believed to be the most comprehensive publicly available database of its kind.

About The Medill Justice Project

The Medill Justice Project, founded at Northwestern University in 1999, is an award-winning national investigative journalism center that examines potentially wrongful convictions, probes national systemic criminal justice issues and conducts groundbreaking research. As journalists, MJP advocates only for the truth.

For more information:

Prof. Alec Klein, Northwestern University
Director, The Medill Justice Project
(847) 467-4476
alec-klein@northwestern.edu

Source: The Medill Justice Project

Share:


Categories: Investigative News

Tags: criminal justice, Northwestern University, Steven Slutzker, The Medill Justice Project, wrongful conviction


Additional Links

About The Medill Justice Project

View Website

The Medill Justice Project, founded at Northwestern University in 1999, is an award-winning investigative journalism center that examines potentially wrongful convictions, probes systemic criminal justice issues and conducts groundbreaking research.

The Medill Justice Project
1845 Sheridan Rd
Evanston, IL 60208
United States