Louisville Attorney Gladstein: Rand Paul Verdict Should Silence Critics of KY Tort System

Seth Gladstein

Jury award of compensation and punitive damages sends a message that state’s civil justice system works to help victims of negligence and intentional harm.

Louisville personal injury attorney, Seth Gladstein, sees the recent Warren County jury verdict, awarding compensatory and punitive damages to U.S. Senator Rand Paul, as proof of how the civil justice system works to provide fair compensation to victims of the negligent and intentional harm caused by others. The senator sued his neighbor after the man attacked him in what has been described as a long-running dispute over piles of brush the senator had on his property.

“The civil justice system has been under attack in Kentucky with critics seeking to limit the right of injured people to recover adequate compensation for harm done to them by others,” according to Louisville personal injury attorney, Seth Gladstein. “The Rand Paul lawsuit illustrates how unfettered access to our civil justice system is preferable to so-called “tort reform” that serves only to limit the ability of people to be fairly compensated for their injuries.”

A long-standing dispute between two neighbors became violent when Senator Paul was tackled by his next-door neighbor, a retired physician. The attacker entered a guilty plea in federal court to assaulting a member of Congress and received a sentence that included 30 days incarceration and probation supervision for one year, along with a $10,000 fine.

The senator suffered several fractured ribs when his neighbor tackled him. The victim received outpatient treatment for the broken ribs and for pneumonia that he and his doctors attributed to the injuries suffered in the attack. After hearing from witnesses, including both parties in the lawsuit, the jury awarded the senator almost $8,000 toward his medical expenses, $200,000 for pain and suffering, and $375,000 as punitive damages.

According to attorney Gladstein, Kentucky civil law allows someone to recover punitive damages when the evidence establishes the other party acted with malice – which is defined as intentional conduct engaged in knowing it will cause bodily injury to the victim. The purpose of punitive damages awards is to punish a wrongdoer while sending a message to others who might contemplate engaging in similar conduct. 

“The Rand Paul lawsuit proves how wrong it is for critics of our civil justice system to continue their efforts to prevent the victims of negligence and intentional conduct from recovering the compensation they need and deserve,” said attorney Gladstein.  

About Gladstein Law Firm, PLLC

Seth Gladstein began his legal career defending medical professionals against medical malpractice claims. He now devotes his practice to representing victims of medical malpractice and all types of accidents, including motor vehicles, slip and fall, workplace and construction, and wrongful death.


Seth Gladstein, Esq.
Gladstein Law Firm, PLLC
1041 Goss Avenue #1
Louisville, KY 40217
(502) 855-417

Source: Gladstein Law Firm, PLLC

About Silva Injury Law

If you have been injured in an accident, you are likely feeling the pressure of handling physical injuries, medical bills, lost wages, and other expenditures. You may feel lost, and have unanswered questions about how to proceed with your case. At Silva Injury Law, Inc., we provide our clients with answers and compassionate support. We practice law with the highest ethical standards in the legal profession and achieve positive results, skill, and a dedication to working hard for you.

Silva Injury Law
2130 Geer Rd , #Suite A
Turlock, CA

More Press Releases