Mortgage Expert from CRE-Finance Explains Non-recourse Loans with Bad Boy Carve-outs
A non-recourse commercial real estate loan is NOT personally guaranteed by the borrower. If the real estate investment goes bad, the borrower can usually walk away from the property. There are several exceptions, known as carve-outs.
Eatontown, NJ, October 3, 2014 (Newswire.com) - Finding a non-recourse commercial real estate loan is far more legally sophisticated than merely finding a commercial lender "foolish enough" to make a commercial loan to a borrower who wants to reserve the right to simply walk away from his obligation according to Todd Tretsky from CRE-FInance. He also says "Sometimes there are important legal reasons why a commercial loan simply must be a non-recourse loan". We'll discuss some of these important legal reasons further below.
A non-recourse commercial real estate loan is a loan that is NOT personally guaranteed by the borrower. If the real estate investment goes bad, the borrower can usually simply walk away from the property.
According to Tretsky, there are around seven to ten common exceptions, known as carve-outs, to this basic rule. If the borrower commits certain Bad Boy Acts - fraud, intentional waste (taking a sledgehammer to the walls), toxic contamination, placing a second mortgage on the property without permission, failure to maintain fire insurance on the property, failure to pay the real estate taxes, misappropriation of a condemnation award or any fire insurance proceeds, or certain criminal acts by the borrower - then many non-recourse commercial loans becomes a full-recourse loans. The borrower becomes personally liable states Tretsky.
Finding a non-recourse commercial real estate loan is far more legally sophisticated than merely finding a commercial lender "foolish enough" to make a commercial loan to a borrower who wants to reserve the right to simply walk away from his obligation according to Todd Tretsky from CRE-FInance. He also says "Sometimes there are important legal reasons why a commercial loan simply must be a non-recourse loan"
"However, absent the commission of some Bad Boy Act by the borrower, a commercial lender cannot come back after the borrower for a deficiency suffered as a result of making a non-recourse commercial real estate loan" according to Todd Tretsky. A deficiency is a loan loss left over after the property is sold in foreclosure.
Obviously commercial lenders are not crazy about the idea of making non-recourse commercial loans. In fact, since the Great Recession the vast majority of all commercial banks making portfolio commercial loans today absolutely insist on a personal guarantee by the borrower.
A portfolio commercial loan is a commercial loan that the lender intends to keep in its own portfolio, as opposed to a commercial loan that the lender intends to later sell off in the secondary market. CMBS lenders and ABS lenders (subprime commercial lenders who sell their scratch-and-dent commercial loans to Wall Street pools) are examples of commercial lenders who are not portfolio lenders.
According to Tretsky the bottom line is since the vast majority of all commercial loans made today are made by commercial banks and credit unions, non-recourse commercial lenders are fairly rare. If you happen to meet a commercial correspondent lender Cre-Finance - who is willing to make a non-recourse commercial loan, be sure to make a note of it.
Here is what CRE-FInance says regarding when is it legally necessary for a commercial loan to be non-recourse.
1. Let's suppose you own a commercial property in your IRA. You may not legally personally guarantee your commercial loan from the bank without running afoul of the IRS. Personally guaranteeing your IRA's commercial loan, in the opinion of the IRS, lowers the interest rate to your IRA and is a form of disallowed contribution. (Code Section 4975(c)(1)(B))
2. Commercial loans to Tenant-in-Common (TIC) investments must be non-recourse; otherwise the investments lose their tax-deferred qualification.
3. Certain irrevocable trusts have a trustee who is separate from the beneficiary, such as a family attorney serving as the trustee for the minor child of a deceased client. If a balloon payment comes due on a commercial property owned by the irrevocable trust, the trustee certainly isn't going to be willing to guarantee some $800,000 new commercial loan.
Categories: Real Estate